{"id": "card_n_e2d17695863a", "kind": "note", "title": "Pilgrim's Progress §158: MEN.", "body": "MEN. Seen! Why, the Valley itself, which is as dark as pitch; we also saw there the hobgoblins, satyrs, and dragons of the pit; we heard also in that Valley a continual howling and yelling, as of a people under unutterable misery, who there sat bound in affliction and irons; and over that Valley hangs the discouraging clouds of confusion. Death also doth always spread his wings over it. In a word, it is every whit dreadful, being utterly without order. CHR. Then, said Christian, I perceive not yet, by what you have said, but that this is my way to the desired haven. MEN. Be it thy way; we will not choose it for ours. So, they parted, and Christian went on his way, but still with his sword drawn in his hand, for fear lest he should be assaulted.", "source": {"label": "John Bunyan, Pilgrim's Progress (1678)", "url": "", "ref": "§158", "authority_tier": "external_aligned"}, "shelf": "classics", "box": "pilgrims_progress", "bands": ["pilgrim", "bunyan", "allegory", "Job 3:5; 10:22", "Jer. 2:6", "Job 3:5"], "connections": [{"to_card_id": "card_n_e44d29ee3677", "relationship": "same_section", "origin": "nesting_2026_06_12"}, {"to_card_id": "card_n_e2140485b2c4", "relationship": "same_section", "origin": "nesting_2026_06_12"}, {"to_card_id": "card_n_67ae646e6c3f", "relationship": "shares_scripture", "evidence": "Jer. 2:6"}, {"to_card_id": "card_spine_classics", "relationship": "member_of", "evidence": "a member of the classics shelf in the keeping"}], "author": "engine", "created_at": "2026-05-19T13:07:21.372457+00:00", "updated_at": 1784810203.396128, "visibility": "public", "lifecycle_stage": "public", "volatility": "permanent", "metrics": {"paperclips_count": 0, "helpful_count": 0, "not_helpful_count": 0, "cite_count": 4, "walks_through_count": 0, "flagged_count": 0}, "source_hash": "96ba4af5f2566bbb4967e0acb31910e1ac3761c6ca3a68c755d257b3e53e7df7", "witnesses": [{"class": "manuscript_tradition", "label": "First edition Nathaniel Ponder, London 1678 — original imprint", "ref": "Ponder-1678"}, {"class": "critical_edition", "label": "Oxford World's Classics — Roger Sharrock, 1960/1984", "ref": "Sharrock-OWC"}, {"class": "republication", "label": "Project Gutenberg — Pilgrim's Progress", "url": "https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/131", "ref": "PG-131"}, {"class": "republication", "label": "Internet Archive — multiple editions", "url": "https://archive.org/search?query=pilgrim%27s+progress+bunyan", "ref": "IA-Bunyan"}, {"class": "non_government_archive", "label": "Christian Classics Ethereal Library", "url": "https://www.ccel.org/ccel/bunyan/pilgrim.html", "ref": "CCEL-Bunyan"}, {"class": "citation_tradition", "label": "Cited extensively by Spurgeon, Edwards, modern Reformed writers", "ref": "Spurgeon-Edwards-cites"}], "witness_status": "passed", "witness_status_reason": "6 witnesses across 5 independence classes: ['citation_tradition', 'critical_edition', 'manuscript_tradition', 'non_government_archive', 'republication']", "surface": "secular", "presentation": {"glyph": "•", "kind_label": "pilgrims progress", "by": "John Bunyan, Pilgrim's Progress (1678)", "authority": "external_aligned", "posted": "", "standing": ""}, "neighbors": [{"id": "card_n_e44d29ee3677", "title": "Pilgrim's Progress §238: There was an Act made in the days of Pharaoh the Great, servant to our prince, that les...", "relationship": "same section", "why": "", "href": "/card/card_n_e44d29ee3677", "resolved": true}, {"id": "card_n_e2140485b2c4", "title": "Pilgrim's Progress §259: And now to the second part of the question, which concerns the tradesman you mentioned.", "relationship": "same section", "why": "", "href": "/card/card_n_e2140485b2c4", "resolved": true}, {"id": "card_n_67ae646e6c3f", "title": "Pilgrim's Progress §155: Now, at the end of this valley was another, called the Valley of the Shadow of Death, a...", "relationship": "shares scripture", "why": "Jer. 2:6", "href": "/card/card_n_67ae646e6c3f", "resolved": true}, {"id": "card_spine_classics", "title": "The classics — the great books, kept whole", "relationship": "on the shelf of", "why": "a member of the classics shelf in the keeping", "href": "/card/card_spine_classics", "resolved": true}]}