{"id": "card_n_e09e7b97f84c", "kind": "note", "title": "Pilgrim's Progress §202: To others, it is thus discovered: 1.", "body": "To others, it is thus discovered: 1. By an experimental confession of his faith in Christ. 2. By a life answerable to that confession; to wit, a life of holiness, heart-holiness, family-holiness, (if he hath a family), and by conversation-holiness in the world which, in the general, teacheth him, inwardly, to abhor his sin, and himself for that, in secret; to suppress it in his family and to promote holiness in the world; not by talk only, as a hypocrite or talkative person may do, but by a practical subjection, in faith and love, to the power of the Word. And now, Sir, as to this brief description of the work of grace, and also the discovery of it, if you have aught to object, object; if not, then give me leave to propound to you a second question.", "source": {"label": "John Bunyan, Pilgrim's Progress (1678)", "url": "", "ref": "§202", "authority_tier": "external_aligned"}, "shelf": "classics", "box": "pilgrims_progress", "bands": ["pilgrim", "bunyan", "allegory", "Rom. 10:10, Phil. 1:27, Matt. 5:19", "John 14:15, Ps. 50:23, Job 42:5-6, Eze. 20:43", "Rom. 10:10", "Phil. 1:27", "Matt. 5:19"], "connections": [{"to_card_id": "card_n_e2140485b2c4", "relationship": "same_section", "origin": "nesting_2026_06_12"}, {"to_card_id": "card_n_de99ca939171", "relationship": "same_section", "origin": "nesting_2026_06_12"}, {"to_card_id": "card_c_c8470bfb9736", "relationship": "shares_scripture", "evidence": "Job 42:5"}, {"to_card_id": "card_c_36ca97bc3e39", "relationship": "shares_scripture", "evidence": "John 14:15"}, {"to_card_id": "card_c_c7f10096ecb6", "relationship": "shares_scripture", "evidence": "Romans 10:10"}, {"to_card_id": "card_n_abb3b70be485", "relationship": "shares_scripture", "evidence": "Romans 10:10"}, {"to_card_id": "card_spine_classics", "relationship": "member_of", "evidence": "a member of the classics shelf in the keeping"}], "author": "engine", "created_at": "2026-05-19T13:07:21.427621+00:00", "updated_at": 1784810207.134468, "visibility": "public", "lifecycle_stage": "public", "volatility": "permanent", "metrics": {"paperclips_count": 0, "helpful_count": 0, "not_helpful_count": 0, "cite_count": 4, "walks_through_count": 0, "flagged_count": 0}, "source_hash": "266920385c50d0560255fb345986543220a3e5c1ac3a88827b2db33f8defb584", "witnesses": [{"class": "manuscript_tradition", "label": "First edition Nathaniel Ponder, London 1678 — original imprint", "ref": "Ponder-1678"}, {"class": "critical_edition", "label": "Oxford World's Classics — Roger Sharrock, 1960/1984", "ref": "Sharrock-OWC"}, {"class": "republication", "label": "Project Gutenberg — Pilgrim's Progress", "url": "https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/131", "ref": "PG-131"}, {"class": "republication", "label": "Internet Archive — multiple editions", "url": "https://archive.org/search?query=pilgrim%27s+progress+bunyan", "ref": "IA-Bunyan"}, {"class": "non_government_archive", "label": "Christian Classics Ethereal Library", "url": "https://www.ccel.org/ccel/bunyan/pilgrim.html", "ref": "CCEL-Bunyan"}, {"class": "citation_tradition", "label": "Cited extensively by Spurgeon, Edwards, modern Reformed writers", "ref": "Spurgeon-Edwards-cites"}], "witness_status": "passed", "witness_status_reason": "6 witnesses across 5 independence classes: ['citation_tradition', 'critical_edition', 'manuscript_tradition', 'non_government_archive', 'republication']", "surface": "secular", "presentation": {"glyph": "•", "kind_label": "pilgrims progress", "by": "John Bunyan, Pilgrim's Progress (1678)", "authority": "external_aligned", "posted": "", "standing": ""}, "neighbors": [{"id": "card_n_e2140485b2c4", "title": "Pilgrim's Progress §259: And now to the second part of the question, which concerns the tradesman you mentioned.", "relationship": "same section", "why": "", "href": "/card/card_n_e2140485b2c4", "resolved": true}, {"id": "card_n_de99ca939171", "title": "Pilgrim's Progress §265: Neither will it out of my mind, but that that man that takes up religion for the world,...", "relationship": "same section", "why": "", "href": "/card/card_n_de99ca939171", "resolved": true}, {"id": "card_c_c8470bfb9736", "title": "Easton: Repentance cites Job", "relationship": "shares scripture", "why": "Job 42:5", "href": "/card/card_c_c8470bfb9736", "resolved": true}, {"id": "card_c_36ca97bc3e39", "title": "Easton: Works, Good cites John", "relationship": "shares scripture", "why": "John 14:15", "href": "/card/card_c_36ca97bc3e39", "resolved": true}, {"id": "card_c_c7f10096ecb6", "title": "Heidelberg Q61 ↔ Romans", "relationship": "shares scripture", "why": "Romans 10:10", "href": "/card/card_c_c7f10096ecb6", "resolved": true}, {"id": "card_n_abb3b70be485", "title": "Heidelberg Q61", "relationship": "shares scripture", "why": "Romans 10:10", "href": "/card/card_n_abb3b70be485", "resolved": true}, {"id": "card_spine_classics", "title": "The classics — the great books, kept whole", "relationship": "on the shelf of", "why": "a member of the classics shelf in the keeping", "href": "/card/card_spine_classics", "resolved": true}]}